What is Equalized Odds?
The Mathematical Definition
Equalized odds has two requirements. First: P(Ŷ=1|Y=1,A=0) = P(Ŷ=1|Y=1,A=1). Among people who truly qualify (Y=1), approval rate should be equal. Second: P(Ŷ=1|Y=0,A=0) = P(Ŷ=1|Y=0,A=1). Among those who do not qualify, false approval rate should also be equal. If 90% of qualified women get approved, 90% of qualified men must too.
Why This Matters
Unlike demographic parity, equalized odds respects ground truth. If Group A has more qualified applicants, they get more approvals, but the model treats qualified and unqualified individuals from both groups equally. A medical diagnostic should catch 95% of cancer cases in both men and women. A fraud system should flag 5% of legitimate transactions falsely in both groups.
The Core Limitation
Equalized odds assumes ground truth labels are correct. If historical labels were biased (qualified women labeled unqualified), equalized odds perpetuates bias. It also requires ground truth for evaluation, which may not exist. For loan default, you only know if someone defaults after giving them the loan. Without outcomes for rejected applicants, measuring equalized odds is impossible.